OK, be honest, a tight condom doesn't mean small. Someone like a hard pillow and someone like a soft pillow, there is nothing wrong to use a tight condom. Also, there is another type of enjoyment with a skin-on-skin sensation that only a tighter condom can give you this feeling.
Of course, make sure the condom not being oversized is also very important. Make sure when you do the measurement, do it on the base, which is most important for making sure it doesn't come off.